InFisherman, FishHawk and OOS photos

[Michael]

InFisherman has a clear-cut policy of not publishing photos of OOS fish. I don't think they're in any way affiliated with PETA. In implementing such a policy, do you feel they are "looking down upon" or being "judge and jury" toward anglers who catch and photo OOS fish?

Do "we" (the Fish-Hawk community) want to simply reflect the broader culture of fishing (the good the bad and the ugly)?

Do we want to lead by example (like In-Fisherman)?

Sounds like a good poll topic...

[Rex Mundi]

I don't want to ruffle any feathers but I think OOS Fish pictures is like cheating. The fish was not caught leagally in season so posting pictures is cheating in my view.

[Big Fisher]

I don't want to ruffle any feathers but I think OOS Fish pictures is like cheating. The fish was not caught leagally in season so posting pictures is cheating in my view.

Cheating at what?? Taking a picture doesnt change the fact you caught an OOS fish...

[steve-hamilton]

i made a post, but deleted it.

my only comment that should have stayed was, i hope this place doesn't turn into a place where you have to worry about every post you make, due to the 'post police'.

[Big Fisher]

i made a post, but deleted it.

my only comment that should have stayed was, i hope this place doesn't turn into a place where you have to worry about every post you make, due to the 'post police'.

too late..

I think a 3rd choice should be added..

"Don't care..."

[canoedude]

i made a post, but deleted it.

my only comment that should have stayed was, i hope this place doesn't turn into a place where you have to worry about every post you make, due to the 'post police'.

I don't think anyone wants that to happen - this is referring to a very specific issue that has come up OVER and OVER again. Personally, I hope it is resolved and that there is a policy developed either way. The discussions are always circular in nature, don't resolve anything and usually become inflammatory.

I'd like to see FH.net take a position (again, either way - it's not my message board), articulate that position in the rules section, and then have everyone live by them (e.g., leave those alone who post pics OR not allow members to post photographs of OOS fish).

Canoedude

[Big Fisher]

i made a post, but deleted it.

my only comment that should have stayed was, i hope this place doesn't turn into a place where you have to worry about every post you make, due to the 'post police'.

I don't think anyone wants that to happen - this is referring to a very specific issue that has come up OVER and OVER again. Personally, I hope it is resolved and that there is a policy developed either way. The discussions are always circular in nature, don't resolve anything and usually become inflammatory.

I'd like to see FH.net take a position (again, either way - it's not my message board), articulate that position in the rules section, and then have everyone live by them (e.g., leave those alone who post pics OR not allow members to post photographs of OOS fish).

Canoedude

Good idea...

[banjo]

I thought there was already a set of guidelines
http://www.fish-hawk.net/hawktalk/viewtopic.php?t=2548

[fishforfun]

Posting OOS pics definately seems to stir a normally good natured group of anglers into taking sides and debating the issue to death! I for one would consent to a gentlemans agreement between the more frequent posters which will include most who will read this, that we abstain from any future such postings. Making it a rule will only lead to newbies, youngsters and others being lynched by vigilantes enforcing the rule. Lets continue to educate and bury this thing once and for all! Then the only OOS pics you see, will give those who wish the opportunity to steer the angler differently through the use of the PM!!
Martin

[saskie]

Posting OOS pics definately seems to stir a normally good natured group of anglers into taking sides and debating the issue to death! I for one would consent to a gentlemans agreement between the more frequent posters which will include most who will read this, that we abstain from any future such postings. Making it a rule will only lead to newbies, youngsters and others being lynched by vigilantes enforcing the rule. Lets continue to educate and bury this thing once and for all! Then the only OOS pics you see, will give those who wish the opportunity to steer the angler differently through the use of the PM!!
Martin

Amen

[RJ]

I'd like to see FH.net take a position (again, either way - it's not my message board), articulate that position in the rules section, and then have everyone live by them (e.g., leave those alone who post pics OR not allow members to post photographs of OOS fish).

Bottom line....people can't leave people alone.....if it's not pics...its how its held....what you caught it on.....etc.......

Just yesterday we had everyones on the sites morals ripped thru the mud because someone mentioned using live bait for muskies....you've got to be kidding me...

I'm personally so tired of hearing people chastisizing others....noone here is a Saint....and who made everyone else their judge?...I just don't get it....

I could start so many threads about what I think is wrong with what's goin on.....but I prefer to talk about fishing...and not the "politics" that surrounds it...

Good Luck to all who get out to fish this weekend....and when you are out there....think for a minute....and perhaps a new perspective on the big picture will arrive....hope so....


RJ

[jammer]

That aboy RJ GOTCHA loud and clear!!

[big-o]

This Subect is old and tiresum...we have beaten it to death, again and again....So lets drop it. I'll be so glad when bass season opens....and all this poop will stop

[SkeeterJohn]

This Subect is old and tiresum...we have beaten it to death, again and again....So lets drop it. I'll be so glad when bass season opens....and all this poop will stop

DITTO!

OOS Pics well if it bothers some oh well... how about those guys who were caught with 40 oos bass in their possession... how about that muskie shot where the fish is being held wrong... how about those that think tournements are wrong.. those that... well ths list is endless really.

oos pics are not illegal there's nothing stating that clearly in the regs.. until there is i have no problem with those that do it.

So do we also ban photos of muskie held vertically... etc.. come on guys get real!

[Big Fisher]

Couldnt have said it any better RJ...