question.guide/client number off rod.

[dh99]

Where I fish open water in the winter on memphremagog we are only allowed 1 if you are fishing on the ice you are allowed 5 lines.

http://www.mrnf.gouv.qc.ca/publications ... asp#nombre

I thought this applied everywhere but I guess not.

DH

[Wallyboss]

dh Memphre is one exception.

[joco]

here is the answer frome the mnr(quebec) in french. for winter fishing.

La Rivière des Outaouais, est située dans la zone 25.
Dans cette zone, le nombre de lignes autorisé pour la pêche d'hiver est de 5
(Sauf le Lac Témiscamingue où le nombre de lignes est de 2),
Tu as donc le droit d'utiliser jusqu'à 5 lignes dans la période comprise entre le 20 décembre et le 31 mars (C'est ce que l'on appelle la pêche d'hiver)

Cela n'a pas d'importance qu'il y ait de la glace ou non.
S'il y a encore des endroits à l'eau claire (non gelés) tu as le droit d'utiliser le nombre de lignes autorisé pour la pêche d'hiver, soit 5.
(Il faut quand même que ces lignes soient sous la surveillance constante et immédiate du pêcheur qui les utilisent)

Il y a fort longtemps que le règlement a été changé.

Plusieurs personnes sont encore sous l'impression qu'elles n'ont pas le droit d'utiliser plus d'une ligne à la fois lorsqu'il n'y a pas de glace.

Autrefois, on parlait de pêche sur la glace.
(En fait, il s'agissait de pêche sous la glace)
Aujourd'hui, on utilise l'expression: ''Pêche d'hiver''

Il n'est pas obligatoire que ce soit des brimbales, tu peux utiliser le genre de cannes à pêche qui te plaît et utiliser les leurres autorisés qui te plaisent.


this is an answer wallyboss receive after a question he ask to the mnr guy...great question and WOW answer.i never thaught that at all.
that was a great question wallybos..


so from now on.if the water is open i will sher fish wit more then one line.. (its legal why not) at least 2 rod.. .



joco

[RJ]

Ridiculous regulation really...

Div 25 which in PQ is the Ottawa River...

Between Dec 20 and Mar 31st...5 lines are allowed...and nowhere does it say it has to be on ice....

Man they drink alot of "cinquante" over there...

[joco]

Man they drink alot of "cinquante" over there.




if you could read the french response you could realy see that there is nothing about tip up or rod or ice or not.its just dates only...

so if guy see a guy after those dates wit 5 rods.its legal.if there 2 guys.10 rods.if you have a 30 feet pootonn wit 10 guys 100 rods all around. .

joco

[RJ]

Joco,

I can read your Frenglish so I can read that response... It is just another example of how the PQ and Ontario MNR's are miles apart on things....

RJ

[joco]

I can read your Frenglish so I can read that response.





yep quebec and ontario mnr.so mutch deference.some good and bad on both side...

frome number off rods to live bait to fishing wit lights etc..


same thing for hunting on both side..


joco

[g unis]

a great debate. i prefer 2 rods for musky. its been flogged to death.. here on the great lakes in 08 it will be standard issue. for walleyes in erie to lake st clair. if the body of water can handle it why not. actually on erie walleye quotas for sportfishing are never met. commercial netters get 99.6 per-cent and anglers get o.4 per cent.. as for muskies 96.5 per cent are released. we had a biologist state we had to many muskies for the waters. . it really up to mnr and biology that proves the facts.

[steve-hamilton]

joco, what about the fishing shows at quinte in october/november/december...

do you think the camera guy(s) can also put their rods out? of course they can!

so now, for ONE fishing host, they have the hosts's two rods, the guides two rods, the camera guys two rods, now we have SIX rods for one host....

its all about working the regs....

[Trophymuskie]

Ok Joco think of it like you are fishing with a buddy and you are taking turns. I guess you're fishing with 2 rods then as well. Only difference with a guide is that he'll be skipping his turn.

Hey when we are casting and I get a big fish on I'll offer it to the clients, I see it as a trolling fish. I mean these guys are paying me $500 a day to catch trophy muskies so I do everything legal to get them those trophies.

You should be complaining about the guides using 4 rods even if only with one client.

A lot of times guys go out and fish together and one guy offers his rod to the other and sometimes let him catch fish all day, same as guiding except the client's are paying for the extra rod.

BTW with my 8 years of guiding experience I can tell you now that I get to fish with 2-3 rods all the time that we're not catching that many more fish. If a fish is there and hungry it will hit the one lure it sees or one of the 3 lures it sees.

[joco]

your a guide........that answer was expected.

and say it all......

you say...

Only difference with a guide is that he'll be skipping his turn.

except the client's are paying for the extra rod.

you said it all.......we all understand........

people that want to fish wit more rod.have to hire a guide............that is it.


my point was..........everybody is supose to be on the same level same reg....why its alwasy about $$$$$...


its not worth more comment frome me.



i said in the first tread not go over wit this.....

[Joey Rat]

Actually I think it depends where you are and what type of fishing. For example on the BOQ I beleive you are allowed 2 rods per person if you are on the outside of the Glenora ferry. On the in side Picton Bay you are only allowed one rod.

Perhaps Eye Tracker or someone could confirm.

[titowoody]

Five rods in your yak, you would look like a Russian Spy Trawler . Didn't realize la Belle Province had the regs worded as they are. I am originaly from l'Abitibi, pretty hard to have open water after Dec 20.

They might have to change the regs with all this warming going on.

Cheers

tW

[joco]

hi titoowoody

hows the kayak fishing bud...


you said..pretty hard to have open water after Dec 20.

i hope it would hrd..but last year we had open water till mid janurary and some part off the river is alwasy open (to mutch current).

actualy....i DONT OPEN WATER.......i want ICE.... .


hope to see you soon tito..



for the number off lines...this subject is close.better that way.everything have been said and i dont like controversy...mabe i shoud have not start that tread.. .


joco....

[Badger Shark]

Titowoody, You are allowed 2 rods on the east side of the ferry and one on the inside.