Fish-Hawk.Net

I do not wish to start controversy but I am somewhat at a lost over the recent interest in carp these last few decades. When I was a kid fishing on the detroit river for carp we would destroy them if we could, since we were told that they eat the eggs of bass and walleye. They also seem to crowd out sport fish and take over ponds and rivers since they seem to be prolific breeders and tough as grandma. We even refered to them as garbage fish along with suckers. Am I missing something.

joseph wrote: Am I missing something.

No.........

hi joseph.

go catch a couple over 20 or 30 pound and you will no why.

there tons off fun to catch and they are a strong and tuff fish.

they guive a great fight..a lot better then any musky or walleye or a lot off other species . truly.

and in europe carp is like very very popular..actualy if you look for the most popular sportfishing.its carp fishg.

yep if you are talking world wide carp fishing is way more popular then bass or walleye way more not even close .


try it its to adopt it....

just pure fun.

joco

Man do they every fight!

I caught my first one this summer, only about a 12 pounder, but was a heck of a fight! Way more fighting power than bass.

Next year i'll be trying for some carp again

easily accessable from shore.

can live in a sewer.

get big.

3 reasons they are fished for.

Bass Addict wrote:

joseph wrote: Am I missing something.

No.........

I grew up along the Susquehanna River in Pennsylvania. I, like you was taught they are a garbage fish.........I still feel that way.

I also realize people will spend a huge pile of money to travel to the St. Lawrence River to fish carp on the Ontario and New York sides......


DropShot'r

Why carp?








Why not

One thing to remember Joseph............

If you do take up carp fishing ,, they can look into your soul

Speaking of which I haven't seen or heard from FishingisHealing in a long time now....

I knew he was in bad health...hope he is ok!

J

joseph wrote: When I was a kid fishing on the detroit river for carp we would destroy them if we could, since we were told that they eat the eggs of bass and walleye.

Hi Joseph - what part of Essex County did you grow up in ? I'm originally from Amherstburg, and we used to also catch a lot of Carp in the Spring - I had even nicked named my sister-in-law "Carp Catcher" as she really enjoyed the fight they put up. Sadly she is no longer with us.

personnally I don't target them but I can see the attraction. big fish, fairly easy to catch and lots of opportunities. I was speaking to some Brits that were on carp vacation down by Iroquois this Fall. They told me that this area is regarded as the premier carp fishing location in the world so maybe we are missing out on something?? They did get the idea of bass fishing when I took them for a quick run in the Ranger though.

one more thing

caro is some countries is like delicasy...you eat some only in special times..like here turky on thankgiving. very speciale meal.


i am not saying and go ahead and eat some..but its not worst theh anything helse.

people misjuge carp..they think what other people are saying or have been saying.

carp receipies.

http://www.fishingsociety.org/CarpRecipes.html

http://www.activeangler.com/recipes/carp.shtml

http://www.bassonhook.com/fishforfood/carprecipes.html

http://www.idfishnhunt.com/eatcarp.htm

but keep the small ones...healthyer for you and we get to catch monster.


again there fun to catch.







joco

joseph wrote:I do not wish to start controversy but I am somewhat at a lost over the recent interest in carp these last few decades. When I was a kid fishing on the detroit river for carp we would destroy them if we could, since we were told that they eat the eggs of bass and walleye. They also seem to crowd out sport fish and take over ponds and rivers since they seem to be prolific breeders and tough as grandma. We even refered to them as garbage fish along with suckers. Am I missing something.

I like how you lumped suckers in there too. Not liking carp because they're "not native" is one thing, but suckers...c'mon!! To some people anything thats not classified as a "gamefish" is automatically garbage, and it is this moronic attitude that leads to ling being left to die on the ice, or gar having their beaks broken before being thrown back...

for a lot off people crappies are garbage fish to..some fliping them on rocks etc.

its a none sense.

bass is close to be garbage in europe..

joco

Bass Addict wrote: Are you some kind of crybaby/treehugger or something




Man ,,get a life

Are u saying that u agree with killing fish for no reason???

I agree with wolfman, people who kill native fish just cause they dont ''like them'' are petty much being d!cks.