Who's is bigger?

[lapointeric]

Neither pike is big, but naturally it's still a fierce debate.... And obviously I'm referring to the one in my left hand vs the pike in the second pic.





Cheers,

E

[Mick]

Hard to say, the one in the bottom pic looks longer to me.

But the one in your left hand is interesting. Did you cut it open? Looks like a really big bulge. I wonder what's inside

[toned]

bigger - weight = top one
bigger - length = bottom one

[TheMaverick]

The bigger fish is always in the eye of the beholder

[rex.stpierre]

Bottom one is longer but the top one has a perch in him so he might weigh a tad more. Just go out and catch another one to settle the debate!!!

[cprince]

bigger - weight = top one
bigger - length = bottom one

Agreed!

Craig

[lapointeric]

Looking back on the photo, I don't remember seeing his belly being that full... we filleted him, but didn't check out the stomach... wish I would have.

Thanks folks. I guess the debate will go on.

E

[lapointeric]

The bigger fish is always in the eye of the beholder

But we're both beholders!

E