I could get into a long winded discussion regarding the various fishing platforms that are available, but in a nutshell they each have their specific niche, and hence their own strengths and weaknesses. Regardless of the type of watercraft, the selection is essentially based on the following basic requirements:
- Transport - Do I have the capability to transport the watercraft from my house to where I'm going to parking the car/truck?
- Deployment - How far do I have to haul the watercraft from the vehicle to get it into the water?
- Handling - Do you require hands-free control?
- Fishing Style - Trolling? Casting? Drifting?
- Water Body Size - How much water do I need to cover to get to my fishing spot?
- Safety - Will I require a watercraft that handles high waves or class rated whitewater?
With the exception of safety, there is no right or wrong with respect to the type of watercraft selected, rather it's a personal choice, albeit not necessarily the best choice for a particular situation. My personal opinion is that if you look at any one type of watercraft, it will most likely excell in 20% of the situations and be adequate in say another 20% of the situations. In this respect there is no "one size fits all" watercraft. You'll find that the hardcore fishermen will have two if not three different types of watercraft.