Dragged my Dad down to NY last minute for some nice fall trout fishing with my good buddy Simon (thanks Dad!) . The plan was to wake up early, head to Malone then head to Wilmington to fish the fabled Ausable River and return home for a late dinner. In my fairly limited experience in New York State I have fished some more productive rivers than the Ausable but it remains my favourite. Such beautiful gorges and waterfalls coupled with smart brown trout make for a fun time on the water.
The morning started at a well stocked river downstream of Malone. The plan was to catch some fish before heading to the Ausable just in case it was slow. In two and a half hours of fishing I brought 26 trout to hand (all released of course) and was ready to pack up and head to Wilmington. It was a mixed bag of mostly rainbows (maybe 2/3) and some browns, wild and stocked. The biggest was a nice 14 inch wild brownie caught czech nymphing a fast run.
After scouting out the water it was both clear and low and we were a little worried. There was minimal surface activity, although we may have left too early to see any.
To my surprise in a few hours fishing I brought 16 trout to hand as well as quite a few lost, including a a nice brownie that got off from a jump. It was about 50/50 rainbows and browns. The rainbows were nicer than the ones caught in malone with nice jumps and runs. The highlight was a nice 16 inch brownie caught using a big ausable bomber close to the cliff, and 5 Minutes later seeing Simon catch a hen of the same size long lining a hare's ear nymph. Most fish we caught were about 10-12 inches long and stacked at the top of the pockets. Stealth definitely helped, and we stayed as low and as quiet as possible.
We high sticked nymphed using small tungsten pheasant tails and hares ear nymphs to fish the pockets. The closer to the access points the harder the fishing was, and a few trout I caught had hook marks in their mouths. Man those trout get pounded: I wouldn't want to live at monument falls if I were a trout

Can't wait to head there next year, and I would reccomend to head down there, definitely a nice time to fish as Ganman once said, the trout are stronger and smarter, and no bugs fall is the best time to be out!
Mike